Sentences should be longer, with automatic minimum jail terms for repeat offenders.
Three Strikes was reinstated in 2024. ACT proposes extending it to burglary, with no parole, home detention or early release on a third conviction.
ACT
Strongly supportsCampaigning on adding burglary to the three-strikes regime, with a minimum three-year sentence and no parole or home detention.
Newswire: ACT's three strikes for burglaryGreens
Strongly opposesStrongly opposed, argues the focus should be on 'preventing harm happening in the first place'.
Green Party: Manifesto 2026Labour
OpposesOpposed reinstating Three Strikes, arguing mandatory minimums produce unjust outcomes without reducing crime.
NZ Herald: Labour on coalition crime policiesNational
Strongly supportsReinstated Three Strikes, capped sentence discounts at 40% and removed repeat discounts for youth and remorse.
National: Restoring law and orderNZ First
Strongly supportsSupports the coalition's sentencing reforms and consistently campaigns on tougher penalties.
Sentencing (Reinstating Three Strikes) Amendment Act 2024Te Pāti Māori
Strongly opposesStrongly opposed, argues mandatory sentencing deepens the over-incarceration of Māori.
Te Pāti Māori: Policy
What this means in practice
Three Strikes imposes escalating mandatory sentences for repeat serious offending, removing judges' discretion. It was repealed in 2022 and reinstated in 2024. ACT proposes extending it to burglary, with a minimum three years and no parole or home detention on a third conviction.
Supporters say
- Repeat offenders commit a large share of crime; keeping them in prison prevents it directly.
- Victims deserve to know a serious repeat offender will actually serve time.
- Sentencing discounts had stacked up to the point where sentences didn't reflect the offending.
Opponents say
- Mandatory minimums produce unjust results in cases nobody anticipated when writing the law.
- Evidence suggests certainty of being caught deters far more than sentence length.
- The cost of imprisonment could fund policing or rehabilitation that prevents more crime.